Store brand ice cream heating up competition

Store brand ice cream heating up competition

Ice cream is among the largest supermarket food categories, one of only ten with double digit billion dollar sales. Given the high standing of ice cream among the food categories in retail groceries, it isn’t surprising that store brand/private label products should be so prominent, accounting for nearly 20% of all frozen dessert sales, packaged and novelties combined, and as much as half the sales in the sherbet/sorbet/water ice category. Another reason for retailers to want in on ice cream sales via their private label products is that ice cream is an expensive category for retail stores, as it must be kept frozen and a lot of space must be given over to the category in order to keep up with the plethora of ice cream brands and varieties that consumers want to choose among.

Ice Cream's Place Among Billion Dollar Supermarket Categories

Sales of private label frozen desserts have grown steadily over the last couple of decades. In recent years, about two-thirds of consumers have come to accept that private label frozen desserts are equal in quality to name brand frozen desserts. This perception is based in reality, as private label frozen desserts have been on a steady rise in terms of quality over the past three decades.

Level of Agreemennt with the Statement: Store Brand Ice Cream is as Good Quality as Name Brand Ice Cream, 2014 vs 2016 (percent of U.S. adults)

Premium and Superpremium Frozen Desserts Upgrade Private Label Perceptions

The starting point was the explosion in quality among branded frozen desserts marked by the expansion of superpremium ice cream sales and a burst of activity in the premium category. Economy and regular ice creams lost ground as consumers, once they had a taste of the “good stuff,” had a hard time accepting anything else. As a result, private label frozen desserts, which accounted for a lot of the low-end activity, were being squeezed out of the market. Viewing the success of premium products, retailers opted to get on the bandwagon and the improvement of private label frozen desserts was underway.

Of course, frozen desserts wasn’t the only food category in which this trend was taking place. Across the board, private label products were being upgraded as consumers shifted from a purely lowest price approach to shopping to a price/value approach which weighed significantly in the acceptance of the new, upgraded, private label products. Also becoming a factor in private label sales increases for frozen desserts and other foods was the expansion of upscale, specialty, and natural food retail chains such as Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s which actively promote their store brands as top quality offerings as good as any branded products, with the same flavors that are trending as consumer favorites, as for example with Whole Foods Caramel and Sea Salt “Authentic Italian” Gelato. 

Private Label Future Sweetens With Expanding Natural, Organic, and Clean Label Products

Looking ahead there are good reasons to believe that private label ice creams and other frozen desserts will continue to gain market share. Retailers are expanding their offerings with more organic and natural products as well as jumping on the clean label bandwagon with products positioned for their absence of artificial ingredients. And they ae continuing to match the branded products in terms of popular flavor trends as they emerge, whether its Peanut Butter and Jelly from Wegman’s or Birthday Cake from HEB.

-- by Howard Waxman