Non-traditional Financial Services to the Unbanked, Underbanked and WhyBank? in the U.S.

Aug 1, 2007
211 Pages - Pub ID: LA1383052
Attention: There is an updated edition available for this report.
Abstract Table of Contents Search Inside Report Related Reports

Chapter 1 Executive Summary
  • Scope and Methodology
  • Report Methodology
  • Financial Services for the Unbanked, Underbanked and WhyBanks
    • Most Unbanked Previously Owned a Checking Account
    • Over 40% of U.S. Workers Are Underbanked.
    • WhyBanks? Are Driven by Convenience and Price

  • Americans Spend $12.6 Billion on 1.2 Billion Nontraditional Financial Services
    • Hispanics Heavily Represented in Unbanks and Underbanks
    • Remitters Spend $3 Billion Sending Money to Latin America
    • 13,000 Check Casher Process $63 Billion Worth of Checks
    • Payday Lenders Will Earn Almost $7 Billion in Fees
    • The Traditional Money Order
    • From 2007 to 2011, Growth Will Move to New Venues and Products
      • Packaged Facts Predicts $200 Billion on Prepaid Debit Cards in 2011
      • Table 1-1 By Segment, Growth of Nontraditional Financial Services, 2002-2011

    • U.S. Economics Grows the Numbers of At-Risk Consumers
      • Subprime Mortgage Defaults
      • Midwestern Consumers are Particularly Vulnerable
      • Wealth Is Increasingly Concentrated While Real Incomes are Falling
      • Borrowing By The Working Poor Has Soared
      • Debt is Becoming Increasingly Expensive For the Middle Class
      • Healthcare Uninsureds and Bankruptcies Will Swell Ranks of Underbanked and WhyBanks?
      • Medical Bankruptcy Filers are Middle Class Americans

    • Who Are the Unbanked?
      • Contrary to Common Perceptions, the Unbanked Aren’t Being Gouged
      • Banks are Increasingly Dependent on Fee Income and Unbanked are Least Able to Afford Fees

    • Who are the Underbanked?
      • 70% of Banked Use Non-Bank Services

    • ChexSystems Exiles - The 8 Million Can’t Banks
      • ChexSystems Runs the “Get Checking” Program

    • Who Are the WhyBanks?
      • WhyBanks? Turn to Payday Lenders for Short-Term Loans

    • Payday Lending Users
    • Prepaid Debit Cards Strongly Appeal to the WhyBanks?
      • Prepaid Debit Users are Working Class with Blemished Credit

    • Prepaid Payroll Card Users
    • Products and Their Marketers
    • Wire Transfer Cos.
      • After Averaging Yearly Volume Increases of 23%, Wire Transfer Volumes Flat
      • Western Union Dominates Wire Transfer Industry
      • MoneyGram
      • GSM Association and MasterCard Enter Mobile Phone Remittance Marketplace

    • Prepaid Remittance Cards
    • Payday Lenders and Check Cashers
      • ACE Cash Express
      • Dollar Financial

    • Innovative Retailers
      • Enter Western Union to facilitate commerce.
      • 7-11 Leads the Convenience Store Herd
      • 7-Eleven Competitors Rushed to Add Similar Kiosks
      • 7-Eleven’s Financial Services Aspirations Derailed by Core Business Challenges
      • FAMSA Helps Latinos Establish Credit in the U.S.

    • Banks Offer Wire Transfer/Check Cashing Services and Safety Net/Basic Services Checking Accounts
      • Citibank
      • JP Morgan Chase
      • Union Bank of California
      • Bank of America
      • Wells Fargo
      • Wells Fargo May Join BofA in Offering Credit Cards to Undocumenteds
      • KeyBank

    • Latin American/European Banks Enter the Market
      • Banco Popular
      • BBVA

    • Prepaid Card Products
      • MasterCard Adds rePower to Green Dot Network
      • Green Dot Anticipates 2007 Revenues of $2 Billion
      • Discover Jumps on Prepaid Debit Wagon
      • NetSpend, All-Access National Savings Program Links Prepaid Debit and Savings Account; Savings Account Pays 3%
      • Capital One Decoupled Debit Card
      • Prepaid Debit Cards Must Launch Valuable Rewards Programs
      • Safeway’s Blackhawk Natural Network for Rewards Program
      • Wal-Mart/Green Dot Natural Rewards Partnership
      • Bank Regulators Could Hamper Future of Prepaid Debit
      • $80 Billion Gift Card Market Mainstreamed Consumers’ Acceptance of Prepaid Products
      • Payroll Card Market Exploded with Visa/MasterCard Network Inclusion
      • Ecount Survey Finds 54% of Payroll Cardholders are Banked Using Direct Deposit

    • Alternative Financial Services
      • PayPal: More Customers than American Express; More Secure Than Competitors.
      • BidPay
      • Google Checkout
      • BYOB (Be Your Own Bank) -- Peer2Peer Lending
      • New Labor’s Sigo Card
      • Get Checking Program

    • Case Study: The Wal-Mart Effect
    • Kroger Storefronts Offering Financial Services

Chapter 2 Market Size and Growth

  • Highlights
  • Scope and Methodology
  • Report Methodology
  • Definitions
  • Americans Spend $12.6 Billion on 1.2 Billion Nontraditional Financial Services
    • Unbanked - no checking or savings accounts
    • Federal Reserve Finds Unbanked to be Young, Low-Income and NonWhite
    • Table 2-1 Types of Transaction Accounts Owned by Families, 2001 - 2004
    • Most Unbanked Previously Owned a Checking Account
    • Table 2-2 Distribution of Reasons Cited By Respondents For Their Families Not Having a Checking Account, By Reason, 1995-2004 Surveys, (Percent)
    • Checking Account Ownership by Individuals is Lower Than For Families
    • Hispanic Unbanked

  • Simmons Research Details Characteristics of the Truly
  • Disintermediated
    • 14.8 million Americans Have No Bank Account, No ATM/Debit Card and No Credit Card
    • Table 2-3 No Bank Account, No ATM/Debit Card and No Credit Card

  • Underbanked Have Checking or Savings Accounts, But Rely on Non-bank Financial Services Providers
    • Check Cashing and Payday Lending
    • Table 2-4 Pay Day Lending Industry, Number of Transactions and Revenues (2000-2006)
    • Table 2-5 Retail Outlets of Publicly Held Companies Offering Check Cashing, 2006

  • Wire Transfers
    • Unbanked and Underbanked Immigrants are Key Users of Wire Transfer Services
    • Table 2-6 Global Flows of International Migrant Remittances to Developing Countries and Globally, in Billion $ (2000-2006)
    • From 2001-2010, Wire Transfers to Latin America Will Total $500 Billion
    • Table 2-7 Remittances to Latin America (2000 - 2010)
    • Indian Immigrants Are Heavy Users of Wire Transfer Services
    • Table 2-8 U.S. Migrant Remittances to India Dollar Value and Growth, 2000-2006
    • Immigration is Changing the U.S.
    • Table 2-9 Immigrants to the United States, By Region and Country, Percentage and Number, 2004
    • Unauthorized Foreigners Make Up 5% of U.S Workforce
    • Table 2-10 Size and Growth of the U.S. Labor Force Age 16 and Older, by Nativity, 1994 and 2004
    • Figure 2-1 Cumulative Change in Population, 1995-2050 Prepaid Debit Cards
    • Packaged Facts Predicts $200 Billion on Prepaid Debit Cards in 2011
    • Table 2-11 Prepaid Debit Card Market 2003 - 20011 (Dollars in $Billion))
    • Market Share of Prepaid Debit Cards
    • 2008 and 2009 Will Be Breakthrough Years for Prepaid Cards-$200 Billion Market by 2011

  • The Emerging Suite of Features for Prepaid Cards
    • Rewards Programs Tied to Prepaid Cards Have Huge Unrealized Potential
    • Tying Credit Building/Repaid to Prepaid Cards Will Appeal to Some Consumers
    • Packaged Facts Forecasts Automated Savings Tied to Prepaid Cards as a Hit with Consumers.
    • Consumer Level Prepaid Card Customization Will Become Product Norm Within 4 Years

  • Peer-2-Peer Lending As a Credit Alternative for Underbanked and WhyBanks?
    • P2P Lending Obstacles
    • More Niche Players in the Niche P2P Lending Market
    • Table 2-12 Venture Capital Backing and Consumer Excitement Will Make U.S. P2P Lending a $5.3 Billion Market by 2012
    • Viral Marketing is Building P2P Community

  • The Traditional Money Order
    • Money Orders are Stockpiled for Large Ticket Purchases
    • Traditional Money Orders are Disappearing
    • Table 2-13 U.S. Money Order Market Share the United States, 2007
    • Table 2-14 The Death of the Money Order, 2007 - 2011
    • Seismic Shifts in Venues and Products are Coming in the Next 5 Years.

  • By Product, Growth of Nontraditional Segments, 2002-2011
    • Table 2-15 By Segment, Growth of Nontraditional Financial Services, 2002-2011

  • U.S. Economics Will Grow The Numbers of At-Risk Consumers
    • At Risk Consumers Have Strained Relationships with Banks
    • Table 2-16 Indicators for Economic Concern
    • Americans Have No Savings Safety Net
    • Table 2-17 Americans’ Self-Reported Savings (Excluding Home and Pension), by Age and Work Status
    • Subprime Mortgage Defaults Will Disintermediate Borrowers

  • How Resets Affect Mortgage Payments
    • Increasing Recession in the Midwest
    • Continued Shrinkage of the Historically Middle Class
    • Borrowing By The Working Poor Has Soared
    • Healthcare Uninsureds Will Swell Ranks of Financially-at-risk Consumers
    • Medical Expenses are the Leading Cause of Bankruptcy Filings
    • Table 2-18 Consumer Bankruptcy Filings, 2000-2006

  • Medical Bankruptcy Filers are Middle Class Americans
  • Buffeted Consumers Most Receptive to Nontraditional Financial Services Providers

Chapter 3 The Consumer

  • Highlights
  • Who are the Unbanked?
    • Only 63% of Immigrant Households Own a Checking Account
    • Table 3-1 Share of U.S. Immigrant Heads of Households Who Have Checking/Savings Accounts, 2006
    • Conventional Wisdom is Lack of Bank Branches Responsible for Unbanked Consumers
    • Table 3-2 The Unbanked, 2007
    • Contrary to Common Perceptions, the Unbanked Aren’t Being Gouged

  • How the Unbanked Receive Income
  • Unbanked Spending on Financial Activities
    • Table 3-3 Unbanked Spending on Financial Services
    • Table 3-4 Where Checks Are Cashed

  • Unbanked May Cash Checks at Banks, But Seldom Obtain
  • Other Services
    • Banks are Increasingly Dependent on Fee Income and Unbanked are Least Able to Afford Fees
    • The Immigrant Unbanked

  • Who Are the Underbanked?
    • 40% of Americans Living Paycheck-to-Paycheck
    • Underbanked Have No Savings Cushion For Emergencies
    • 70% of Banked Use Non-Bank Services

  • ChexSystems Exiles - The 8 Million Can’t Banks
    • What is ChexSystems?
    • ChexSystems Runs the “Get Checking” Program
    • What is the Relationship Between ChexSystems and the Unbanked?
    • Table 3-5 Select Characteristics of Former Checking Account Owners and Those Who Have Never Had a Checking Account

  • Who Are the WhyBanks?
    • WhyBanks? Turn to Payday Lenders for Short-Term Loans
    • Table 3-6 How Banked and Underbanked Conduct Financial Activity

  • Banks May Offer No Savings to the Unbanked/Underbanked
    • Banks Cheaper Alternative For Only 17% of Unbankeds

  • Growing Role of Immigrants in the U.S. Economy
    • Figure 3-1 Industries in Which Immigrants Work (%)
    • But Marketers Can’t Ignore 12 Million Undocumented Immigrant Consumers
    • Illegals are Marketed to Like Other Consumers
    • Figure 3-2 Number of Undocumented Immigrant Arrivals (in millions)
    • Growth in U.S. Immigration at 70-Year High
    • Immigrants Moving Throughout the U.S.
    • Figure 3-3 Total Foreign-Born and Percentage Foreign-Born in the United States, 1900-2000
    • Unbanked Hispanics Have Unique Characteristics

  • Understanding the Unbanked Hispanic
    • Lack of Documentation is Barrier to Account Ownership
    • Undocumented Immigrants Fear Rules Will Change and Be Used Against Them
    • Banks Cheaper For Wire Transfers, But Nonbanks Trump Based on Convenient Locations

  • Internet-based Products and Immigrants
    • Most Latinos Use the Internet
    • Table 3-7 Characteristics of Latinos Using the Internet
    • Latinos Online Also Own Cell Phones

  • Payday Lending Users
    • Payday Loan Customers Steadily Employed But Have Damaged Credit

  • Ace Cash Express Customer Demographics
  • Dollar Financial Check Cashing Customer Demographics
    • Payday Lenders Target Working Class, Not Poor

  • Prepaid Debit Cards Strongly Appeal to the WhyBanks?
    • Prepaid Debit Users are Working Class with Blemished Credit
    • Prepaid Cards Attractive to Bank Customers Afraid of Bounced Check Fees

  • Prepaid Payroll Card Users
    • 54% of Prepaid Card Users were Banked With Direct Deposit

  • Prepaid Cards: Spending Habits of Banked and Unbanked
    • Table 3-8 Prepaid Card Spending Categories, Banked vs. Unbanked, 2006

Chapter 4 Products and Marketers

  • Highlights
  • Products and their Marketers
  • Wire Transfer Cos.
    • Most Migrant Workers Heavy Users of Remittance Services
    • After Plummeting, Wire Transfer Costs Have Stagnated
    • Acquisitions in the Wire Transfer Space

  • Western Union
    • Table 4-1 Western Union: Revenue, Revenue Growth and Transactions (2002-2006)
    • In Just 5 Years, Western Union Nearly Tripled Its Number of Outlets
    • Table 4-2 Western Union: Revenue as a Percentage of Total Segment Revenue (2004-2006)
    • Western Union Gold Card is a Successful Rewards Scheme Driving Transaction Volume
    • Western Union is a Target for Consumer Advocates

  • Vigo
  • MoneyGram
    • Table 4-3 MoneyGram: Revenues and Revenues Growth (2004-2006)
    • MoneyGram’s Growth Focused on Europe

  • GSM Association and MasterCard Enter Mobile Phone Remittance Marketplace
    • GSMA and MasterCard Try to Speed Standardizations for Cell Phone Remittances

  • Prepaid Remittance Cards
    • Fewer Than 7% of Remitters Have Tried Remittance Cards
    • Celent Estimate: 11% of Remittances are by Card
    • Card-Based Remittances Will Grow With New Marketers, Technology and Prices

  • Payday Lenders and Check Cashers
    • Banks Exit Short-Term Credit Market So Payday Lenders Step Into Opportunity
    • Payday Lenders Reorganized as Credit Services Organizations or Became Self-Funding

  • Advance America
    • Table 4-4 Advance America: Stores, Loan Numbers and Revenue (2002-2006)
    • In Texas, Advance America Changed from Payday Lender to CSO
    • In Michigan, Advance America Now Charges “Check Presentment
    • Deferment Fees”

  • ACE Cash Express
    • Table 4-5 Ace Cash Express Store Growth (2003-2006)

  • Dollar Financial
    • Table 4-6 Dollar Financial: Stores and Payday Lending/Check Cashing Fees (2002-2006)
    • Future Growth for Dollar will Come from American West, Canada and the U.K.

  • QC Holdings
    • Table 4-7 QC Holdings Store Growth (1999-2006)

  • Innovative Retailers
    • Enter Western Union to facilitate commerce.
    • 7-11 Leads the Convenience Store Herd

  • 7-Eleven’s Financial Services Aspirations Derailed by Core Business Challenges
    • FAMSA

  • The Future of FAMSA and Mexican Businesses
  • How is FAMSA Doing So Far?
  • Banks Offering Wire Transfer/Check Cashing Services and Safety Net/Basic Services Checking Accounts
    • Banks Own About 5% of U.S. Remittance Market

  • Citibank
    • Citibank and Banamex Game to Test New Strategies to Target Hispanics

  • Bank of America
    • BofA Markets Credit Cards to Undocumented Immigrants

  • JP Morgan Chase
    • Chase Introduced Rapid Cash Account Featuring Free Wire Transfers
    • Direct Benefit Card, a Prepaid Card Targeted to Low-Income Consumers

  • Union Bank of California
  • Wells Fargo
    • Wells Fargo May Join BofA in Offering Credit Cards to Undocumenteds

  • KeyBank
    • KeyBank Offers More than Check Cashing

  • Latin American/European Banks Enter the Market
    • Banco Popular
    • BBVA Acquires U.S. Banks to Market to U.S. Hispanics

  • Acquisitions Make BBVA Largest Bank in the Sunbelt
  • Prepaid Card Products
    • Card Swap Websites Turn Gift Cards into Payment Instruments
    • Visa, MasterCard, American Express and Discover Wade into Well Established Markets
    • Payroll Cards Surge In Popularity With Visa and MasterCard Support

  • Visa Introduced Payroll Card in 2001, Then Added Features
  • MasterCard’s Payroll Card Offers Extensive Network For Reloads
  • Payroll Processors Also Promote Payroll Cards
    • Visa and MasterCard Target Unbanked With Prepaid Debit Cards

  • Visa’s ReadyLink
  • MasterCard Launches Its rePower Network Through InComm
    • American Express
    • Discover Jumps on Prepaid Debit Wagon
    • InComm Eliminates Monthly Fees From Its Prepaid Card Products
    • Green Dot Intends to be THE Universal Prepaid Debit Card Network

  • Green Dot’s Initiatives
  • Green Dot’s Customers
    • NetSpend Introduces “All-Access” Debit-Based Savings Account

  • NetSpend Pays $10 Million for Vince Young Endorsement
    • Trycera Financial
    • Table 4-8 Trycera’s Gross Dollar Volume 2004 - 1 Qtr 2007

  • Prepaid Cards with Credit
    • Starbucks Duetto Card

  • Revel Card is First Prepaid Debit Card with Line of Credit
  • Revel Card to Target Military Personnel and Unbanked/Underbanked Native Americans
    • Unbanked, Underbanked and WhyBanks? Get Tax Refunds on Prepaid Cards

  • Intuit’s TurboTax Marketed Russell Simmons Tax Refund Card to Young, Unbanked Tax Filers
  • Alternative Financial Services on the Internet
    • PayPal

  • More Customers than American Express; More Secure Than Competitors.
  • PayPal Testing Text-to-Buy
    • BidPay
    • Google Checkout

  • BYOB (Be Your Own Bank) - P2P Lending is New Credit Alternative for Underbanked and WhyBanks?
    • How P2P Lending Works -- Prosper.com
    • Loan Funds Deposited in Pooled Accounts to Mitigate Risk
    • More Niche Players in the Niche P2P Lending Market

  • FDC and the Traditional Money Order

Chapter 5 Marketing Strategies

  • Highlights
  • Introduction
  • National Community Reinvestment Coalition (NCRC)
    • NCRC Focuses on Branch Availability
    • NCRC Recommendations
    • Assessment of the NCRC’s Strategy
    • The Brookings Institution
    • Strategy Proposed By The Brookings Institution
    • Banks Should Open Specialized Branches Providing Check Cashing Services
    • Advantages of Bank Outlets Over Bank Branches
    • Outlets Should Offer "starter" Deposit Accounts.
    • Outlets Should Offer Accounts Specifically Designed to Build Savings.
    • Outlets Should Seek Community-based Partners and Offer Financial Literacy Programs.
    • Assessment of the Brookings Strategy
    • New Labor’s Sigo Card
    • What Are Worker Centers?
    • What is the Sigo Card?
    • Marketable Advantages of the Sigo Card
    • Sigo Card Designed as Win-Win Product
    • Assessment of the Sigo Card/Worker Center Strategy
    • Get Checking Program for Banking System Exiles
    • Assessment of Get Checking Program

  • Looking Ahead
    • Further Consideration of Open-Loop Prepaid Cards
    • Capital One’s Portable Debit Card
    • Prepaid Debit Cards Must Launch Valuable Rewards Programs
    • Figure 5-1
    • Western Union Gold Card Active Cards
    • Safeway’s Blackhawk Natural Network for Rewards Program
    • Wal-Mart/Green Dot Natural Rewards Partnership
    • Beyond 2007
    • Bank of America Needs to Grow Asian Business
    • HSBC Could Use Prepaid Debit as Complement to Asian Credit Card Strategy

Chapter 6 Retailer Slugfest

  • Highlights
  • Pepe the Penguin vs. The Big Yellow Smiley Face
  • Table 6-1 Number of Wal-Mart Supercenters (U.S.)
  • The Wal-Mart Effect
  • But Not Invincible
  • Table 6-2 Number of Kroger Stores (U.S.)
  • Storefronts Offering Financial Services
  • Table 6-3 Kroger Financial Services Offerings
  • Wal-Mart’s Performance is Dragging
  • Kroger Sales and Stock Performance Continue to Astonish
  • Wall Street
  • Bankers Monitor Wal-Mart’s Every Move
  • Wal-Mart Markets to the Unbanked
  • Table 6-4 Wal-Mart and Its Customers
  • Strike One
  • Strike Two
  • Strike Three
  • Strike Three, Part B
  • Wal-Mart’s Banking Charter Motives Questioned
  • The Financial Services Wal-Mart Offers
  • Table 6-5 Wal-Mart Financial Services Offerings
  • Wal-Mart Building Out MoneyCenter Locations
  • Why Partner With Wal-Mart?
  • Strategies At Play with the Partnerships Wal-Mart Has Already
  • Formed
  • Maintain market leadership
  • Build Brand Name and Tap New Markets
  • Challenge a More Dominant Brand
  • Leverage Wal-Mart Distribution to Capitalize on Emerging Trend
  • Wal-Mart Aggressively Pursues Low-Income Customers
  • Table 6-5 Prepaid Card Fees at Wal-Mart
  • Wal-Mart’s Value Proposition
  • Green Dot - Wal-Mart’s Prepaid Partner
  • Green Dot is a Company to Monitor
  • Financial Services is Growth Focus for Wal-Mart
  • Why Buy A Bank When You Just Act Like A Bank?
  • Table 6-6 U.S. Banks with the Most Branches, May 2007
  • Banking On Mexico
  • Moving Forward

Appendix

800.298.5294
Int'l: +1.240.747.3095
Questions?
Contact a research specialist >

Most Popular Research
Consumer Payment Trends in the U.S.
Underbanked and Unbanked Consumers in the U.S.: Successfully Targeting Consumers of Alternative Financial Services, 2nd Edition
Mobile and Alternative Payment Systems in the U.S., 2nd Edition
Private Label Credit Cards in the U.S., 7th Edition
Pet Insurance in North America, 4th Edition
Regulatory Change and The New Consumer Card and Banking Relationship
Privacy Policy    |    Terms and Conditions    |    Site Map    |    Return Policy    |    Press    |    Help FAQs
Copyright © 2012 Packaged Facts. All Rights Reserved.
A division of Market Research Group, LLC
2/11/2012 - 40
SSL
Contact Us: 800.298.5294 (U.S.)
or +1.240.747.3095 (Int'l)
Hours: Monday - Thursday: 5:30am - 7:00pm EST
Fridays: 5:30am - 6:00pm EST