|
Investment Services for the Mass Market
|
Feb 1, 1998
185 Pages - Pub ID: LA484
|
|
I. Executive Summary
The Market
- Full-Service Brokerage Firms
- Discount Brokerage Firms
- Bank Brokerages
- The Securities Act and the SEC
- The Glass-Steagall Act and Bank Brokerages
- 80 Million Brokerage Accounts
- Brokerage Revenues Exceed $100 Billion
- Full-Service Brokers Claim 80% of Revenues
- 79% of Brokers Are Discount
- Discount Brokers Lead in Growth
- Discount Brokerage Commissions Estimated at Over $2 Billion
- Table 1-1: U.S. Discount Brokerage Commissions, 1993-2002 (dollars)
- 45−54 Is Prime Age Bracket for Investors -54 Is Prime Age Bracket for Investors
- Half of 45-54 Householders Hold Stock
- South Is Investment Services Holdout
- Demographic Tidal Wave Until 2008
- Figure 1-1: Percent Distribution of U.S. Population by Age Bracket, 1995 vs. 2005 (percent): From Age 18 to Age 65 and Over
- Surge in Online Investing
- Flight from Individual Stocks
- Pockets of Substantial Growth
The Marketers
- Full-Service Brokers Remain at Forefront
- Merrill Lynch Leads Among Full-Service Firms
- Morgan Stanley and Dean Witter Merge
- Schwab Claims Half of Discount Segment
- Discount Commissions Grow at 18% Clip
- Online Boom for Discount Brokerages
- Charles Schwab and OneSource
- Banks Gear Up as Rules Relax
- Dean Witter Seeks Bank Bedfellows
- Targeting the New Investor
- Brand Identity Increasingly Important
- Fund Supermarkets Become Common Coin
- Schwab Takes Over Top Advertiser Spot
The Consumer
- One-Tenth of Adults Use Financial Planning Services
- U.S. Savings Bonds Are Most Popular Type of Security
- 5.1 Million Investors Make 1—2 Stock Transactions Yearly
- Over One-Sixth of Adults Have a Brokerage Account
- Full-Service Brokerage Firms Are Most Utilized
- Patterns and Variations by Brokerage Type
- Fidelity Investments Has Highest Number of Brokerage Accounts
- Demographic Variations by Brokerage Firm
- Merrill Lynch Has Highest Number of Primary Users
- One-Fourth of Adults Have a Mutual Fund Account
- Majority of Accounts Held Through Mutual Fund Company
- Indicators by Mutual Fund Provider Type
- Fidelity Investments Has Most Accounts
- Profile of First-Time Mutual Fund Investors
Online Services
- $120 Billion in Securities Traded Online
- Online Revenues at $614 Million
- Online Accounts at 3 Million
- 95,500 Daily Trades
- 60 Marketers, and Growing
- Marketers Answer Consumer Demand
- Charles Schwab Controls 33% of Online Volume
- Price Wars Remain Driving Factor
- Profit Centers Old and New
- Multimillion Marketing of Online Services
- Targeting the High-End Investor
- Shakeout Predicted
Scope and Methodology
- Market Parameters
- Report Methodology
II. The Market
Introduction
- Scope of Report
- Market Structure
The Service Providers
- Full-Service Brokerage Firms
- Discount Brokerage Firms
- Bank Brokerages
- Additional Resources
- Mutual Fund Firms
- Third-Party Providers
- Personal Advisors
- Varying Services
The Regulatory Environment
- SIPC and FDIC
- The Securities Acts of 1933 and 1934
- The SEC and NASDAQ Spreads
- SEC's "Cyberforce" Monitors Online Investing
- SEC's "Plain English" Rule for Mutual Funds
- Regulation T and "Minimum Maintenance"
- National Association of Securities Dealers
- Glass-Steagall Act
Market Size and Growth
- Note on Methodology and Market Estimates
- Over $20 Trillion in Investment, Bank Accounts
- Growing Share of Financial Assets for Investment Vehicles
- Stocks Claim 40% of Investment Assets
- 80 Million Brokerage Accounts
- 3 Million Online Accounts
- Brokerage Revenues Exceed $100 Billion
- Top Ten Brokers Claim Half of Revenues
- One-Fifth of Broker Revenues Earned Through Trading Fees
- Full-Service Brokers Claim 80% of Revenues
- 79% of Brokers Are Discount
- Discount Brokers Lead in Growth
- Discount Brokerage Commissions Estimated at Over $2 Billion
- Table 2-1: U.S. Discount Brokerage Commissions, 1993-2002 (dollars)
- Online Revenues at $614 Million
- Bank Brokerage Profits in $1-Billion Range
- $4.5 Trillion in Mutual Funds
- Cash Inflow to Stock Mutual Funds at $231 Billion in 1997
Consumer Composition of Market
- 45−54 Is Prime Age Bracket for Investors -54 Is Prime Age Bracket for Investors
- Half of 45-54 Householders Hold Stock
- Simmons Data on Use of Investment Services by Region
- South Is Investment Services Holdout
- Table 2-2: Regionality of Use of Investment Services by Type of Account and Firm, 1997 (percent): Northeast, Midwest, West, South
Factors Affecting Market Growth
- Boomers Tuned In to Money Management
- Demographic Tidal Wave Until 2008
- Table 2-3: Percent Distribution of U.S. Population by Age Bracket, 1995—2005 (percent): From Age Under 5 to Age 65 and Over
- Surge in Online Investing
- Online Investment and Bank Brokerages
- Online a Two-Edged Sword for Discounters
- The Full-Service and Online Equation
- Gains Through Mergers and Acquisitions
- The "One-Stop Shopping" Advantage
- The Mutual Fund Factor
- Flight from Individual Stocks
- Mutual Funds at Center Stage?
- The Direct Option
- Risk and Return
Projected Market Growth
- Investment Pool to Surge
- Pockets of Substantial Growth
III. The Marketers
Marketer Overview
- Marketers of Investment Services
- Full-Service Brokers Remain at Forefront
- Multiple and Overlapping Options
- Table 3-1: Selected U.S. Marketers of Investment Products and Services (172 Marketers and Their Firm Type)
The Competitive Situation
- Merrill Lynch Leads Among Full-Service Firms
- The Full-Service Scene
- The Internet Challenge
- Morgan Stanley and Dean Witter Merge
- Merrill Lynch Not Trading Places
- Schwab Claims Half of Discount Segment
- Discount Commissions Grow at 18% Clip
- Online Boom for Discount Brokerages
- Subdividing the Discounters
- Shopping Among the Discounters
- Charles Schwab and OneSource
- Fidelity Focuses on Brokerage Accounts
- Toronto Dominion Aligns Against Schwab
- Banks Gear Up as Rules Relax
- Clearing up Confusion Over FDIC
- Luring Bank Customers
- Banks Face Internet Brokerages
- Schwab Rents Fund Supermarket
- NationsBank Launches Fund, Teams with Schwab
- Dean Witter Seeks Bank Bedfellows
- Banks Expand Offerings Through Mergers
Competitive Profile: Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc
- Corporate Overview
- Entrance Into Supermarkets
- Rewarding the Consumer
Competitive Profile: Morgan Stanley, Dean Witter, Discover & Co
- Corporate Overview
- The Merger
- The Buy Back
- Dean Witter: Low Marks for Pushing Proprietary Funds
- Discover: Top Grade Among Online Brokerages
Competitive Profile: Charles Schwab Corp.
- Corporate Overview
- A Brief History
- Supermarket Investing
- Online Investing
- The Total Customer Access Promise Program Charles Schwab Enhances Services
- Good Relationships with Independent Advisors
- Future Plans
Competitive Profile: Fidelity Investments (FMR Corp.)
- Corporate Overview
- Loosening Grip on Retirement Cash
- Fresh Focus on Consumers
- An Image Makeover
- A Push Towards Online Services
Competitive Profile: Quick & Reilly Group, Inc.
(Fleet Financial Group, Inc.)
- Corporate Overview
- Fleet and Quick & Reilly Acquisition
- Suretrade May Stem Online Slip
Competitive Profile: NationsBank Corp
- Corporate Overview
- Growth Through Mergers
- The Brokerage Business
- A Link with Schwab
- An Internet Alliance
Competitive Profile: First Union Corp.
- Corporate Overview
- The Cap Account
- The Schwab Connection
- Expansion Plans
- A Brand Marketing Crusade
Competitive Profile: KeyCorp
- Corporate Overview
- The Charles Schwab Alliance
Marketing and Advertising Trends
- Targeting the New Investor
- Brand Identity Increasingly Important
- Fund Supermarkets Become Common Coin
- Investment Advertising Tops $1 Billion
- Schwab Takes Over Top Advertiser Spot
- Media Trends: Magazines Dominate
- Charles Schwab: "Independent, Objective"
- Fidelity: "Where 12 Million Investors Put Their Trust"
- Banks Stress Makeover, Regional Expansion
- Samples of Consumer Advertising
IV. The Consumer
Introduction
- Simmons Consumer Survey
- Simmons Data on Investment Services
Consumer Overview: Investment Patterns
- One-Tenth of Adults Use Financial Planning Services
- Indicators and Resisters to Use of Financial Planning Services
- Table 4-1: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Financial Planning Services, 1997 (U.S. Adults)
- U.S. Savings Bonds Are Most Popular Type of Security
- Table 4-2: U.S. Adult Investors by Type of Security Owned, 1997 (total number, median age, and median household income)
- 18.6 Million Adults Own Securities Valued at Under $5,000
- Table 4-3: U.S. Adult Investors by Value of Securities Owned, 1997 (total number, median age, and median household income)
- Indicators for Holding Securities Under $10,000
- Indicators for Holding Securities Over $10,000
- Table 4-4: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Ownership of Securities: By Investment Level: Under $10,000 vs. $10,000+, 1997 (U.S. Adults)
- 5.1 Million Investors Make 1—2 Stock Transactions Yearly
- Table 4-5: U.S. Adult Investors by Annual Number of Stock Transactions, 1997 (total number, median age, and median household income)
Consumer Focus: Brokerage Accounts
- Over One-Sixth of Adults Have a Brokerage Account
- Indicators to Use of a Brokerage Account
- Table 4-6: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts, 1997 (U.S. Adults)
- Full-Service Brokerage Firms Are Most Utilized
- Patterns and Variations by Brokerage Type
- Table 4-7: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Type, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Full-Service Brokerage Firm, Discount Brokerage Firm, Discount Brokerage Through Bank
- Fidelity Investments Has Highest Number of Brokerage Accounts
- Demographic Variations by Brokerage Firm
- Table 4-8a: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Charles Schwab, Dean Witter Reynolds, Dreyfus (Mellon)
- Table 4-8b: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): A.G. Edwards, Fidelity Investments Ids/American Express
- Table 4-8c: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Kemper Financial, Kidder Peabody, Merrill Lynch
- Table 4-8d: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Paine Webber, Prudential Securities, Quick & Reilly
- Table 4-8e: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Shearson Lehman Brothers, Smith Barney
- Table 4-8f: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Brokerage Accounts: By Brokerage Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Other Full-service Firms, Other Discount Brokerage Firms
- Less Than One-Tenth of Accounts Were Closed
- Merrill Lynch Has Highest Number of Primary Users
- Table 4-9: U.S. Adult Investors by Primary Firm Brokerage Accounts, 1997 (total number, median age, and median household income)
Consumer Focus: Mutual Fund Accounts
- One-Fourth of Adults Have Mutual Fund Account
- Indicators for Mutual Fund Accounts
- Table 4-10: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Mutual Fund Accounts, 1997 (U.S. Adults)
- Majority of Accounts Held Through Mutual Fund Company
- Indicators by Mutual Fund Provider Type
- Table 4-11a: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Mutual Fund Accounts: By Type of Firm, 1997 (U.S. Adults): Full-Service Brokerage Firm, Discount Brokerage Firm
- Table 4-11b: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Use of Mutual Fund Accounts: By Type of Firm, 1997 (U.S. adults): Bank, Bank Discount Brokerage, Mutual Fund Company
- Fidelity Investments Has Most Accounts
- Table 4-12: U.S. Adult Investors in Mutual Fund Accounts: By Specific Firm, 1997 (total number, median age, and median household income)
- Profile of First-Time Mutual Fund Investors
- Table 4-13: U.S. Adults Making Their First Investment in a Mutual Fund Account, 1997 (5 Factors)
V. Online Services
Basics of Online Investing
- Advantages to Online Investing
- Value-Added Services
- Dollar Savings as Bottom Line
- Drawbacks to Online Investing
- The SEC and Online Fraud
- Security and Fund Transfer Issues
- Mixed Returns, Bright Future
The Online Market
- $120 Billion in Securities Traded Online
- Online Revenues at $614 Million
- Online Accounts at 3 Million
- 95,500 Daily Trades
The Online Marketers
- 60 Marketers, and Growing
- Range of Marketers
- Table 5-1: Selected Marketers of Online Investment Services (45 Marketers and Their Websites)
The Competitive Situation
- Marketers Answer Consumer Demand
- Charles Schwab Controls 33% of Online Volume
- Datek an Emerging Player
- Price Wars Remain Driving Factor
- Profit Centers Old and New
- Multimillion Marketing of Online Services
- Targeting the High-End Investor
- Full-Service Brokerages Meet the Threat
- Shakeout Predicted
Competitive Profile: Ameritrade Holding Corp
- Corporate Overview
- Ameritrade Consolidates
- "The Way To Trade. Period."
- Teaming Up with Internet Services
- Future Strategy
- Survival of the Fittest
Competitive Profile: E*TRADE Group, Inc.
- Corporate Overview
- "Someday, We'll All Invest This Way"
- Fighting the Competition
- Advertising Target
- E*TRADE Mutual Fund Center
- Future Options
- Stock Surge at WebTV Alliance
The Online Consumer
- Early Adopters
- Under-25s Among the Online Investors
- Online Investors and High-Tech Portfolios
- Online Brokerages Earn Good¾Not Excellent¾Ratings
Appendix I: Examples Of Consumer Advertising
Appendix II: Addresses Of Selected Marketers
|
800.298.5294
Int'l: +1.240.747.3095
Questions?
Contact a research specialist >
Most Popular Research
Underbanked and Unbanked Consumers in the U.S.: Successfully Targeting Consumers of Alternative Financial Services, 2nd Edition
Mobile and Alternative Payment Systems in the U.S., 2nd Edition
Private Label Credit Cards in the U.S., 7th Edition
Pet Insurance in North America, 4th Edition
Millennials in the U.S.: Trends and Opportunities Surrounding Gen-Y Adults
Commercial Payment Cards: The U.S. and Global Markets and Trends, 7th Edition
|