I EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Products
- Market Definition: Cards Used for Business Purposes
- Three Major Categories
- Corporate Cards
- Purchasing Cards
- Business Cards
- Background of Commercial Credit Cards
- How Purchasing Cards Work
- New Types of Purchasing Cards
The Market
- Market to Reach $326 Billion by 2002
- Table 1-1: US Market for Commercial Cards: Dollar Volume of
Transactions, 1993-2002 (dollars)
- Corporate Cards Constitute Bulk of Transactions, But Purchasing and
Business Use Rising
- Figure 1-1: Share of Commercial Card Transaction Volume by
Category, 1997 (percent): Corporate, Purchasing, Business
- 20 Million Cards in Circulation
- Factors Affecting Market Growth
- Different Factors at Play in Commercial Card Market vs
Consumer Market
- Shift to Plastic and Employer Willingness to Provide Cards
Are Pivotal Trends
- Business Market Not Saturated
- Plastic Reduces Costs and Boosts Efficiency
- Market Segmentation to Cover All Bases
The Marketers
- American Express Leads Commercial Card Market
- Twelve Leading Bankcard Issuers
- Another 30 Issuers Have 10,000 Cards or More
- Bankcard Issuers Not the Only Players
- American Express Leads Two of Three Categories
- US Bank Leads Purchasing Card Category
- Mergers Play Dramatic Role in Competitive Situation
- Market Attracts Nonbank Players
- Trend to Combination Cards
- Courting New Markets
- Only $29 Million Spent on Commercial Cards
The Consumer
- Corporate/Business Card Use Not Widespread
- Marriage, Employment, and College Education Indicative of
Corporate/Business Card Ownership
- Cards Not Just for White-Collar Employees
Scope and Methodology
- Scope of Report
- Research Methodology
II THE PRODUCTS
Product Definition
- Cards Used for Business Purposes
- Three Major Categories
- Corporate Cards
- Purchasing Cards
- Business Cards
- Background of Commercial Credit Cards
- The First Purchasing Cards
- Visa and MasterCard Initially Cool to Purchasing Cards
- How Purchasing Cards Work
- Benefits to Users: Slashed Costs
- Other Benefits to Users
- Benefits to Suppliers: Faster Payment
- Benefits to Banks: Profit and Relationships
- New Types of Purchasing Cards
- Additional Products and Terms
- Charge Cards
- Credit Cards
- Bankcards
- Payment Systems
- MasterCard and Visa Payment Systems
- Issuing Banks
- Acquirers or Payment Processors
- Automated Clearinghouse and FedWire
Establishing a Commercial Card Program
- Programs Are Straightforward
- Purchasing Card Programs Require More Planning and Implementation
- Data Requirements More Important Than Supplier Acceptance—At
Outset
- Query Existing Bank Partners First
- Providers Often Help with Implementation
- How a Corporate or Purchasing Card Program Works
- Front-Office vs Back-Office
- Merchant Acquirers and Payment Processors Often Overlap
- One-Stop Shopping Still Not the Norm
- Card Associations Respond
- Leading Merchant Acquirers
- Ten Leading Payment Processors
III THE MARKET
- Figure 3-1: Estimated US Market for Commercial Cards, 1993-1997
(dollars)
Market Size and Growth
- Market Approaches $128 Billion in 1997
- Corporate Cards Constitute Bulk of Transactions, But Purchasing and
Business Use Rising
- Table 3-1: Value and Share of Commercial Card Transactions by
Product Category, 1996 vs 1997 (dollars and percent): Corporate,
Purchasing, Business
- 20 Million Cards in Circulation
- Table 3-2: Estimated Number of Commercial Cards in Circulation: By
- Type, 1997 (number): AmEx, Visa, Fleet Cards, MasterCard,
Other
Factors Affecting Market Growth
- Different Factors at Play in Commercial Card Market vs Consumer
Market
- Shift to Plastic and Employer Willingness to Provide Cards Are Pivotal
Trends
- Business Market Not Saturated
- Industrywide Shift to Electronic Payments
- Federal Mandates Will Speed Transition to Electronic Commerce
- Plastic Reduces Costs and Boosts Efficiency
- Reengineering Trend Boosts Purchase Card Use
- Better Things to Do with Human Resources
- Technology and Merchant Acceptance
- Supplier Complaints Regarding Purchasing Cards
- Bankcard Associations Are True Believers
- Market Segmentation to Cover All Bases
- Electronic Commerce Likely to Compete with Cards
- Figure 3-2: Projected US Market for Commercial Cards, 1997-2002
(dollars)
Projected Market Growth
- Market to Reach $326 Billion by 2002
- Table 3-3: Projected US Market for Commercial Cards by Category,
1997-2002 (dollars): Corporate (T&E), Purchasing, Business
IV THE MARKETERS
Marketer and Brand Shares
- American Express Leads Commercial Card Market
- Table 4-1: Leading Commercial Card Issuers: By Estimated Number of
Cards, Charge Volume, and Market Share, 1997 (number and
dollars): 6 Leading Issuers
- Twelve Leading Bankcard Issuers
- Table 4-2: Leading Bankcard Issuers of Commercial Cards, 1997
(number): 12 Issuers
- Another 30 Issuers Have 10,000 Cards or More
- Bankcard Issuers Not the Only Players
- Fleet Cards a Type of Purchasing Card
- Oil Company Cards Also Used for Fleet Purchases
- American Express Leads Two of Three Categories
- US Bank Leads Purchasing Card Category
Competitive Situation
- Three Associations and Several Independent Players Compete
- Competition for a Relatively Untapped Market
- Market Segmentation About to Change
- Mergers Play Dramatic Role in Competitive Situation
- Globalization of Plastic Payment Industry
- Cost Savings Given; Competitors Focus on Delivering Information
- Big Three Purchasing Card Brands Support Standard Codes
- Technology Plays Major Competitive Role
- Issuers Also Working to Improve Ease of Use
- Competitive Issues in T&E
- Bankcard Issuers Have Advantage in Business Category
- New Products Part of Competitive Strategy
- Perks and Bonus Programs Being Added to Corporate Cards
- Hefty Annual Fees Characterize Reward Programs
- But Purchasing Card Market Not for Everyone
- Market Attracts Nonbank Players
- Competitive Trends in Fleet Card Segment
Competitive Profile: American Express
- The Acknowledged Leader
- T&E Strength Stems from Travel Experience, Extends to New Markets
- Closed-Loop System Gives Greater Control
- More Than 31,000 Commercial Supplier Locations
- Program Offers Flexible Purchasing Limits
- Comprehensive Management Reporting
- No Fees for Purchasing Cards; Per-Card Fees for Others
- Aggressive Supplier Strategy
- Difference Between Corporate and Purchasing Card
- Largest Users Earn Rebates
- Dedicated Commercial Support
- Product Enhancements Under Development
- Strikes Deal with Wright Express
- Strategy Pays Off But Has a Price
- Expands Corporate Card Offerings in Other Countries
- Issuer Develops Credit and Co-Branded Cards
- Changes to Become More Competitive
- Moves Aggressively to Challenge Visa and MasterCard
- American Express Courts Banks for Two Reasons
- Looking for Global Issuers
- A Marriage in AmEx's Future?
- Increasingly Aggressive Advertising
Competitive Profile: Visa USA
- Visa the Largest Bankcard Association
- Visa Helps Members Compete for Commercial Card Market
- Association Bullish on Commercial Cards
- Visa Corporate Cards
- Visa Purchasing Cards
- Visa Business Cards
- InfoSpan 20 Supports Corporate and Purchasing Cards
- Visa Enters Alliance with Score
- Visa Teams with D&B to Develop Market Intelligence for Business Card
Issuers
- Strategy Is to Grow Market Rather Than Compete for Existing Share
- Visa Battles American Express Over Ban on Competing Cards
- Visa and MasterCard Match Programs
- Visa Active in Smart Card Development
Competitive Profile: MasterCard International
- MasterCard Is Second-Largest Association
- The Third-Largest Brand of Commercial Cards
- MasterCard Breaks Rules on Co-Branded Corporate Card, Teams with
British Airways
- Mondex and Smart Cards
- Introduces Premium Corporate Cards
- Introduces World Card
- New CEO to Help Company Focus on Global Market
- Strategy Built on "Four Pillars"
- MasterCard Switches Ad Agencies
- New Campaign Is "Priceless"
- MasterCard Produces Creative Plastic Promotions
Competitive Profile: US Bank
- From First Bank to US Bancorp to US Bank
- The Largest Commercial Bankcard Issuer
- Success Attributed to Size, Economies of Scale, and Stability in Other
Businesses
- Products Tailored to Size of Company
- Started with a Single Client
- First Bank Wins GSA Contract
- Company Expands Corporate Travel Program
- Teams with International Automated Energy Systems to Offer Fleet Card
- Product Enhancements Introduced in 1997
- Company Acquires Lockheed Martin Account in 1997
- Company Manages Four Product Lines
- Acquisition on Ongoing Part of Strategy
Competitive Profile: Citibank
- Second-Largest Commercial Visa Issuer
- The Major Subsidiary of Citicorp
- Global Presence Gives Citibank Edge with Multinationals
- Launches Three Commercial Products in 1997
- Citicorp Processes Cards In-House But Sold Merchant-Processing
Business
- Acquisitions Major Part of Growth Strategy
- Citibank Inherits AT&T's MasterCard Executive BusinessCard Program
Competitive Profile: First Chicago NBD 108
- The Third-Largest Commercial Bankcard Issuer
- The First Private-Sector Purchasing Card Issuer
- Offers Procurement, Fleet, and T&E Purchases on Single Card
- Enhanced Reporting Capabilities
- Offers ProValue SERVICES Software
- Offers T&E Enhancements on Purchasing Card Platform
- Provides Implementation Assistance and Technical Support
- Offers Cards for Smaller Businesses and Fleet/Travel Card
- Merger with Banc One Creates Nation's Fifth-Largest Bank
Competitive Profile: GE Capital
- The Fourth-Largest Commercial Bankcard Issuer
- GE Capital Corporate Card
- GE Capital Commercial Direct for Smaller Businesses
- GE Capital Purchasing Card Program
- GE Capital Fleet Travel Card
- Enhanced Data Capture
- GE Experiments with Different Kind of Reward Program
Competitive Profile: Household Credit Services
- The Sixth-Largest Card Issuer
- Growth Through Acquisition
- Issues MasterCard Corporate Executive Cards
- Enters Smart Card Trial with MasterCard
Competitive Profile: Bank of America
- Sixth-Largest Commercial Bankcard Card Issuer
- Merger with NationsBank Will Create Nation's Largest Bank
- A Major Merchant Acquirer and Card Transaction Processor
Competitive Profile: Paymentech
- Merchant Acquirer/Payment Processor Is Seventh Largest Commercial
- Bankcard Issuer
- Spun Off from First USA
- Offers Several Types of Cards
- Develops Combination T&E/Purchasing/Fleet Card
Marketing and New Product Trends
- Card Issuers Offer Rewards and Enhancement Products
- Trend to Combination Cards
- Smart Commercial Cards
- Courting New Markets
- Direct Mail to Business Owners
Advertising Expenditures
- Big Three Card Brands Spend $574 Million in 1997
- Scant Data on Commercial Card Advertising
- Only $29 Million Spent on Commercial Cards
- American Express Dominates Spending
- Print Plays Major Role in Commercial Card Advertising
- Advertisements Appear in Specialty/Business Publications
Advertising Positioning
- Functionality a Key Theme
- Cost Savings Another Featured Benefit
- Efficiency Akin to Cost Savings
- "Reengineering" a Buzzword
- But Data Capture Critical to Achieving These Savings
- Service Also Key
V THE CONSUMER
Ownership and Use of Corporate/Business Cards
- Note on Simmons Market Research Bureau Data
- Corporate/Business Card Use Not Widespread
- Table 5-1: Ownership and Use of Corporate/Business Credit Cards by
Type, 1997 (number and percent): 7 Types
- Marriage, Employment, and College Education Indicative of
Corporate/Business Card Ownership
- Cards Not Just for White-Collar Employees
- The American Express Corporate Cardholder
- American Express Executive Corporate Profile Similar
- MasterCard Business Cardholders
- Visa Business Cardholders Present Younger Profile
- Table 5-2: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Ownership of
Corporate/Business Credit Cards, 1997 (US Adults): AmEx
Corporate, AmEx Executive Corporate, MasterCard Business,
Visa Business
- Heavy Users Present Different Profile
- Table 5-3: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Heavy Use of
Corporate/Business Credit Cards by Type (US Adults): AmEx
Corporate, AmEx Executive Corporate, MasterCard Business,
Visa Business
- Frequent Users Present More Typical Profile
- Table 5-4: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Frequent Use of
Corporate/Business Credit Cards by Type, 1997 (US Adults):
AmEx Corporate, AmEx Executive Corporate, MasterCard
Business, Visa Business
- College Education, Employment, and $30,000+ Income Indicate
Occasional Users
- Table 5-5: Demographic Characteristics Favoring Occasional Use of
Corporate/Business Credit Cards by Type, 1997 (US Adults):
AmEx Corporate, AmEx Executive Corporate, MasterCard
Business, Visa Business
- Purchasing Card User Survey Reveals Spending Limits
APPENDIX I: EXAMPLES OF CONSUMER ADVERTISING
AND PROMOTIONS
APPENDIX II: ADDRESSES OF SELECTED COMPANIES
AND RESOURCES